I’ve written pretty in-depth reviews of the manifestos for the Welsh election. The whole lot are collated in this blog post here. However, the Western Mail kindly gave me the chance to pen a more condensed version of each. The below article was the best I could edit down to.
The first out of the blocks to publish their manifesto, Plaid Cymru has made education a key plank of its electoral pitch.
There are some exciting and innovative policies that will be very well-received by teachers, parents and pupils alike.
There is a strong focus, as has been the trend over the past few years in Wales, to ensure that the teaching profession are at the heart of the decision-making process.
Plaid has put forward a series of policies that aim to challenge the status-quo and the dreaded buzzword “Pisa” does not escape these pages.
However, the polices around childcare, school improvement, self-regulation and teacher training all offer a clear path to how the party believes it can work with the teaching profession to achieve success.
Perhaps the most eye-catching, head-turning policy in the Plaid manifesto, and arguably of the election for teachers, is the offer of a 10% annual bonus to all teachers who reach certain CPD (continuing professional development) standards.
The party’s aim is two-fold. Firstly, to reinforce the status of teaching as a profession on the same formal standing as doctors, lawyers and engineers and the like.
Secondly, to build professional capacity to ultimately have a master’s level workforce.
As with any policy implementation, of course, will be critical to its success. How can you guarantee all teachers the ability to secure a 10% CPD bonus if we currently have a system where you can’t guarantee all teachers access, or at least equal access in relation to time and quality, of CPD?
Any future Plaid Cymru government would need to win that debate. Certainly, however, the promise of a pay bonus and training will be a combination that plays well on the doorstep with teachers who have seen their pay cut and access to CPD eroded over many years.
Welsh Liberal Democrats
The Welsh Lib Dems have traditionally had a strong focus on education and you can see that influence in their manifesto.
Their lead policy is a commitment to establish a “class sizes reduction fund” of £42m over the next Assembly term to ensure that infant classes normally contain no more than 25 pupils, to give teachers the time to focus on a child’s individual needs, which we believe is central to raising standards.
Class sizes are an issue that are always top of the agenda for the profession, particularly in light of increasingly tight school budgets actually resulting in class sizes going up more often than not.
Aside from this the other big Lib Dem proposal for schools is the expansion of the Pupil Premium.
The pledge is to continue to expand the Pupil Premium and increase the early years’ Pupil Premium every year to reach £1,000 per eligible child by the end of the next Assembly.
The pupil premium was one of the big wins for the Lib Dems during the past Assembly term.
Their negotiations with the Welsh Government secured a major boost for schools and the money was a huge relief for school leaders.
Underfunding of Welsh schools is not a new problem sadly – and it is one that is seemingly getting continually worse.
Any additional funding is always going to be critical and having a continuation of the pupil premium, let alone the proposed increase, is certainly a policy that will register with those on the frontline.
The general policies in the Green Party manifesto are to be welcomed. They offer a positive overview of Welsh education with support for parents and teachers.
The main concern is that while they are a list of ambitions, there doesn’t appear to be that much detail about how they will be achieved.
For example, there is a statement to ensure that all pupils have access to mental health support but no explanation of how this will happen, in what capacity or through what funding.
That said, I think the aims of what is being put forward are more than laudable and would make any Green AM an attractive collaborator to other political parties on education policies at least.
There is a strong support for the Foundation Phase, including a pledge to raise the starting age of formal education, as well as plans to reduce the bureaucratic burden on teachers.
However, perhaps their signature education policy is for class sizes to be capped at 20 in Wales.
This undercuts the Lib Dems’ pledge slightly, going for an even smaller class size number.
Notably, these are the only two parties who have given such prominence to this high-profile concern.
It would have been easy to expect Ukip to produce a manifesto ignoring devolved issues and simply publish an EU referendum campaign document under another name.
However, it has to be said within their manifesto there is a series of thought-provoking, if at times detail-light, education policies.
The Ukip manifesto has some very attractive policies around supply teaching, where the party advocate ensuring that supply teachers are paid in accordance with their position on the salary spine and receive pension rights, cutting out the 30%-50% cost of agencies and saving taxpayer money.
There is also a commitment on tackling the workload crisis including a pledge to decrease the amount of paperwork teachers’ deal with, such as unduly elaborate individual lesson plans, excessive data collection, overly prescriptive internal assessments and dialogue-based marking schemes. Teachers will also welcome the focus on better funding.
However, the headline policy of this manifesto is Ukip’s calls for a return to a discredited and backwards-looking grammar school system, which sadly jettisons the legitimacy of anything else they are putting before the electorate.
Determining the life chances of children based on their perceived ability, as if this is fixed at such a young age, ignores the fact that some pupils develop later than others.
While Ukip cling to that narrow-focused policy, it is pretty hard to give them credibility on other areas.
This manifesto has some interesting themes with polices that should push the other parties into thinking about their offerings.
Ukip have put in work on some areas of interest that should lead to a further debate when they elect AMs.
It is just a shame that there are also some policies that have been shoehorned in here and which would be disastrous for Welsh education, that have undermined the total package on offer.
What we have had from the Welsh Conservatives is a series of policies that are constructive, are largely positive and offer a collaborative way forward.
They are, for the most part, in line with what the profession has been doing and focus on some of the gaps that are already identified and would be welcomed by the profession.
At the same time, they are detail-light and perhaps in some instances do not move the debate on.
The objectives and ambitions put forward by the Conservatives will be welcomed, but may leave readers questioning how exactly they will be achieved and to what end.
Calls to ensure a greater proportion of funding reaches the classroom will be well-received, albeit there will need to be more discussion on what that means for the link with local authorities.
The promise of a veto on school closures for parents and governors will also be attractive in some parts of Wales, particularly in rural communities.
Equally, calling for regional consortia to be scrapped, a plan that has consensus across a number of the manifestos, will certainly register with some teachers who have been left unimpressed by those services.
One big concern is the commitment to “deliver a sustainable and effective school building programme, by embracing elements of a public–private partnership model”.
There is some confusion about how similar this would be to a PFI (private finance initiative) approach, which would naturally send alarm bells ringing.
The timing with the Edinburgh PFI school scandal is not ideal either, putting people once again on edge about the safety and sustainability of such schemes.
Labour were the last of the parties to publish their manifesto and in some senses had the most difficult job.
As the party of government running education in Wales for the past 17 years, it is hard to package a manifesto as offering fresh, new ideas.
In many cases, what we see is a commitment to continue some of the programmes already in place and build on what the party deem to be their key achievements.
The main Labour manifesto was very light on policy but what they have done is produce a separate, education-specific manifesto, to provide a more in-depth breakdown of what they are proposing for the sector if returned to government.
It is a little disappointing there’s no reference to class sizes or workload. There is also a little bit of a vagueness running through the document.
For example, there is a welcomed commitment to a new supply model but no detail as to what Labour believe that should look like.
That said there are some real positives contained within these pages and I think it offers a far more constructive vision than we saw from the previous minister’s “Education Makes a Difference” plan.
This manifesto has a good amount of encouraging policies around supply, curriculum reform and teacher training that creates a platform for greater collaboration with the teaching profession in future.
It appears to build on much of the work that has already been taking place and suggests a continuity of policy.
Some of the key new policies consist of an additional £100m for school standards; pilot “lunch and fun” clubs in the summer school holidays to improve the nutrition of disadvantaged young people; and a “Music Endowment Fund” to help youngsters access music services and instruments.
You can find the original version online here.